Miloš Milikić — Product Designer
← Writing

The good and the bad of AI right now

5 min read

A chat input floating in a dark room, with a glowing amber cursor and the placeholder “Ask anything”.

I hear questions like “What do you think of AI?” all the time, sometimes from other designers, too. And my honest answer is that I’m excited and annoyed at the same time. Sometimes in the same afternoon.

I use AI every day. At work, I use it for design, and for my own apps, I use it for the whole thing. I even rebuilt this website with it. I’m not watching it from the side. This is where I am today. Ask me in six months, and some things will probably be different.

What’s good

The biggest thing for me is that the gap between an idea and a working thing is almost gone.

A while ago I wrote about whether designers should code, and how much I love bringing my designs to life. I could always handle HTML and CSS, but real apps were a different story. Most of my side projects died halfway through, after months of work. Now I’ve developed my own apps with the assistance of AI, something that I couldn’t do on my own. I can sit down with an idea and have something running on my phone after just a few hours. Not finished or great, but real.

It also changed the way I prototype. Figma prototypes have never been great, and you never could feel the real thing. How long the loading takes, what happens when the content gets longer than usual, whether that nice animation is still nice the tenth time you see it… Now you can quickly try all of that in real code and with real data, in a matter of hours, or even minutes.

Then there’s the boring part of the job. Writing a bunch of versions of an empty state message, filling a table with dummy data that doesn’t say “Lorem ipsum”, documenting components… Nobody became a designer to do all of those things, and I’m thrilled to hand those off. That time goes back into the things I like doing, and that actually need me.

And honestly, it’s a great second opinion. When I’m deep in a flow, and I can’t see things clearly anymore, I ask if there’s something I’m missing. Half of what comes back is obvious, but there are usually edge cases I didn’t think about.

What’s bad

Everything is starting to look the same. Same gradients, same rounded cards, same hero sections, same Inter... (Yes, this site uses Inter. I know.) That’s what happens when everyone asks the same tool for the same thing: “clean and modern landing page.” And you get the average of everything the model has seen. That’s fine. It gets a lot better when I give it specific directions, but then you have to know what you want and how to say it, and that was always the hard part.

Now the ✨ button. In the last couple of years, almost every product got that sparkle icon in the corner, and the vast majority of them do mediocre work. Feels like that feature exists so someone can say it exists. But I don’t want to repeat myself, since I already wrote about that.

We spent years trying to make people think less. Clear options, good defaults, and fewer things to remember. And what bothers me a lot now, as a designer, is the chat box. An empty text area is the answer to every UX problem. You have to know what and how to ask, but you don’t know what the outcome will be. I think that is the hardest interface, but I don’t know how we could solve that problem.

It also looks completed long before it actually is. The last 20% takes as long as it did before, even though you get to 80% incredibly fast. Or it can take longer because you didn’t write the code, and you have to understand it. Also, in the beginning, it was a lot of back-and-forth because AI used to change parts that I didn’t even tell it to change. You ask for one small fix, and three other things change with it. It’s better now, but if a junior designer did that, we’d have a talk.

And the one that is most questionable is how people will learn. My taste, or my eye, didn’t come from anywhere special. It came from years of doing work, and mostly bad work. It came from learning from my mistakes, but from others as well. Because of the processes and by doing a lot of manual work, we learned more. If the tools skip those steps and processes, I’m not sure where new generations will learn from. Curious ones will find a way; they always do. But it’s easier than ever to make something that looks completed, and much harder to explain why it is the way it is. That second part is the actual work.

I also don’t like that AI has become an excuse to have fewer designers. I think that comes from people who never knew what designers are actually doing and how they do it.

So how do I feel about this? Mostly optimistic, I think. I’m making and enjoying more than ever. But AI made the making part cheap. Deciding what to make and what to leave out is still on us, and it’s as hard as it ever was.

Making got cheap. Taste didn’t.